7 Costly Towing Mistakes Drivers Make (and How to Avoid Every One)
Mistake #1: Staying in (or right next to) the car on a highway
Roughly 300 people are killed every year in the U.S. while standing near disabled vehicles. If you break down on a highway shoulder:
- Turn on hazards immediately and steer as far right as possible — ideally past the white line plus a full car width.
- Exit through the passenger side if traffic is close.
- Wait behind the guardrail or well off the shoulder, not behind your trunk. A shoulder-struck vehicle gets pushed backward into exactly that spot.
Mistake #2: Accepting help from a tow truck you didn't call
"Bandit towing" is real: a truck shows up minutes after your accident, hooks up fast, and your car ends up at a storage lot charging $75–$150 per day plus a release fee that can top $1,000. Protect yourself:
- Only release your car to a company you or your insurer called by name.
- Ask the driver which company dispatched them — if the answer is vague, decline.
- Photograph the truck, the driver's ID, and your car before it's loaded.
Mistake #3: Not getting the price before the hook drops
A typical local tow runs $75–$125 hookup plus $2–$4 per mile, depending on your market. Winch-outs, after-hours calls, and heavy-duty vehicles cost more — but any legitimate operator will quote you a total (or a tight range) over the phone. Ask three questions before you say yes:
- What's the all-in price to my destination, including hookup and mileage?
- Are there fees for after-hours, dollies, or a second attempt?
- Do you take cards? (Cash-only demands at drop-off are a classic pressure tactic.)
Mistake #4: Towing an AWD or automatic vehicle on two wheels
Dragging the driven wheels of an all-wheel-drive vehicle — or a rear-wheel-drive automatic — can destroy the transfer case or transmission in just a few miles. Repairs commonly run $2,000–$4,000. The fix is simple: AWD and 4WD vehicles should ride on a flatbed, and most modern cars are safest that way regardless. If a company shows up with the wrong equipment, it's okay to send them back.
Mistake #5: The DIY tow strap between two cars
Recovery straps are for pulling a stuck vehicle a few feet — not for towing down public roads. A car in tow with the engine off often has no power brakes and no power steering, and in many states towing with a strap or chain on public roads is illegal. One panic stop and you've bought two repair bills instead of one tow fee.
Mistake #6: Leaving valuables and paperwork behind
Before your car is loaded, take two minutes to grab:
- Wallet, phone, chargers, garage remotes, and anything with personal data
- Your registration and insurance card (you'll need them at the shop)
- Photos of all four corners of the vehicle and the odometer
Those photos take 60 seconds and settle almost every damage dispute before it starts.
Mistake #7: Not knowing what your coverage already pays for
Many drivers pay out of pocket for tows they already bought. Check, ideally today rather than roadside:
- Auto insurance: roadside assistance riders often cost $10–$30 per year and cover towing to the nearest shop.
- New-car warranties: most include roadside assistance for 3–5 years.
- Credit cards and phone plans: several include or discount roadside service.
Save the claim number and your policy's tow-mileage limit (often 15–100 miles) in your phone now.
A 5-step plan for your next breakdown
- 1. Get the vehicle and yourself out of traffic; hazards on.
- 2. Drop a pin and note the nearest exit or mile marker.
- 3. Call a named local towing company or your insurer's roadside line — never accept an unsolicited truck.
- 4. Confirm the all-in price and that the equipment matches your drivetrain.
- 5. Photograph the car, remove valuables, and get a receipt with the company name on it.